Case Result: Syracuse Traffic Charge Dismissed on Consent After the Supporting Deposition Failed to Describe the Offense Charged
On November 9, 2026, a traffic charge against our client in Syracuse City Court was dismissed on the People's consent. After reviewing our motion, the ticket, and the officer's supporting deposition, the Onondaga County District Attorney's Office consented to dismissal. Firm attorney Stacey Pennetti handled the case.
Our client drives a truck for a living and holds a commercial driver's license. For a commercial driver, a moving violation can carry consequences well beyond the fine. As he put it in a review afterward: "As a truck driver, I depend on my CDL to earn a living."
The case is a reminder that a ticket written after an accident still has to describe the offense it charges.
The charge
Our client, an out-of-state CDL holder, was ticketed by the Syracuse Police Department in May 2026 for one violation of Vehicle and Traffic Law § 1128(c), described on the ticket as failing to use a designated lane. A supporting deposition was served with the ticket.
What the deposition said
VTL § 1128 applies only where a roadway "has been divided into two or more clearly marked lanes for traffic." Subdivision (c) covers a specific situation: official traffic-control devices direct certain vehicles to use a designated lane, or designate lanes for traffic moving in a particular direction, and a driver fails to obey them. A charge under that subdivision needs facts showing marked lanes, a sign, signal, or marking designating a lane, and a driver who disobeyed it.
The deposition's entire narrative was one sentence. It said that our client, while attempting a left turn, went over a curb and struck a light pole. It said nothing about marked lanes, nothing about a lane-designation sign or marking, and nothing about disobeying one. As the motion put it, a curb is not a lane marking, and a light pole is not an official traffic-control device.
There was a second problem. The deposition stated that the charge was based on the officer's "information and belief," and it never identified the source of that information. No witness was named and no statement was recited.
The rule
Under CPL 100.25(2), a supporting deposition may rest on personal knowledge or on information and belief, but either way it must contain allegations of fact "providing reasonable cause to believe that the defendant committed the offense or offenses charged." When a deposition is served and does not meet that standard, the simplified traffic information is insufficient on its face (CPL 100.40[2]; People v. Hohmeyer, 70 NY2d 41 [1987]). An officer need not have witnessed the offense (People v. Boback, 23 NY2d 189 [1968]), but conclusory assertions with no disclosed basis are not reasonable cause (People v. Dumas, 68 NY2d 729 [1986]). And facts that might support some other, uncharged violation do not support the one actually charged.
The motion and the result
In August 2026, Stacey Pennetti of our firm moved to dismiss the charge as facially insufficient on both grounds: the deposition alleged no element of VTL § 1128(c), and it rested on unsourced information and belief. She also asked the court under CPL 340.50(2) to allow our client, who lives out of state, to appear through counsel for all purposes, including trial.
On November 9, 2026, the People advised the court that, having reviewed the motion, the ticket, and the supporting deposition, they consented to dismissal of the charge. The charge was dismissed on that consent.
What this means if you were ticketed after an accident
Tickets written at accident scenes deserve a close read. The officer often arrives after the fact, and the section chosen for the ticket does not always match what the paperwork describes. If you were given a supporting deposition, check two things: whether its facts address the elements of the specific section charged, and whether it says how the officer knows what it alleges. One caution: these issues should be raised in a written motion before any plea, and the deadlines are short. Every case turns on its own paperwork.
If you received a traffic ticket anywhere in New York State, call us at 631-724-5251 or email intake@arpinopc.com for a consultation.
Attorney Advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Client-identifying details have been omitted to protect confidentiality.